Texas High Court Declares Mandatory Blood Draws Unconstitutional

Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Declares Mandatory Blood Draw Unconstitutional

State v. Villarreal No. PD-0306-14 (Tex. Crim. App. Nov 26, 2014)

In a 5-4 decision, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (CCA) – the highest court that hears criminal cases in Texas – ruled that a blood draw taken under the mandatory blood-draw statute, without a warrant, was unconstitutional.

Defendant in this case was arrested for felony DWI. His blood was taken without a warrant under the state statute allowing warrantless blood draws for repeat offenders (DWI Third or More). Prior to trial, his motion to suppress the blood was granted on the basis that Missouri v. McNeely made that warrantless blood draw unconstitutional. The State appealed.  The Court of Criminal Appeals agreed.

The CCA ruled that warrantless blood draws do not fall into any of the recognized exceptions to the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement for searches. The warrantless search of a person is unreasonable in this situation, where the primary purpose of the search is gathering evidence. The CCA also rejected the State’s argument that the warrantless blood draw was consensual under implied-consent.

If you have been pulled over for DWI in Galveston County you need an experienced Galveston DWI defense lawyer. Read more info on Driving While Intoxicated, then call our office to discuss your options. Also read your blog entry entitled “Arrested for DWI in Galveston County, Texas – KNOW YOUR RIGHTS AND KNOW THE LAW“.

If you are arrested for driving while intoxicated in Galveston, you have only 15 days after the arrest to request a hearing on the suspension of your driver’s license. Contrary to popular belief, your driver’s license is not automatically suspended.

Our phones are answered 24/7 and a live receptionist is waiting for your call. Don’t delay, seek competent legal representation today. (409) 740-1111

Bayou Vista DWI DUI Defense LawyersClear Lake Shores DWI DUI Defense LawyersDickinson DWI DUI Defense LawyersFriendswood DWI DUI Defense LawyersGalveston DWI DUI Defense LawyersHitchcock DWI DUI Defense LawyersJamaica Beach DWI DUI Defense LawyersKemah DWI DUI Defense LawyersLa Marque DWI DUI Defense LawyersLeague City DWI DUI Defense LawyersSanta Fe DWI DUI Defense LawyersTexas City DWI DUI Defense LawyersTiki Island DWI DUI Defense LawyersBacliff DWI DUI Defense LawyersBolivar DWI DUI Defense LawyersSan Leon DWI DUI Defense LawyersAlgoa DWI DUI Defense LawyersBayview DWI DUI Defense LawyersCrystal Beach DWI DUI Defense LawyersGilchrist DWI DUI Defense LawyersHigh Island DWI DUI Defense Lawyers

Click below to share this post!

Our Galveston, Texas Lawyers are Ready to Represent You!

Full Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Phone Number (required)

Subject (required)

Briefly Describe Your Case (required)

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.