Awards & Media Appearances
The Purpose of Chemical Testing in DWI Cases 
Chemical testing plays a central role in Texas DWI cases. By law, if a driver is suspected of driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, law enforcement has the authority to request a chemical test. The primary goal of these tests is to measure the BAC and determine whether it exceeds the legal limit of 0.08% for adults. There are two main types of chemical tests used in Texas to measure BAC: breath tests and blood tests. Each of these tests has specific protocols, advantages, and limitations that can impact the outcome of a DWI case. Breath Tests: Quick and Convenient, But With Limitations
Breath tests are often the first choice for law enforcement when it comes to measuring BAC. These tests are convenient and can be performed quickly at the scene of the arrest or at a police station. The process is straightforward: a driver blows into a breathalyzer machine, which measures the amount of alcohol in the breath, and the device uses that data to estimate BAC.Key Advantages of Breath Tests
- Speed and Convenience: One of the main reasons why breath tests are preferred is their speed. The results are typically available within minutes, and no special equipment or laboratory is required. This can be particularly useful in roadside situations where officers need a quick assessment.
- Less Invasive: Unlike blood tests, which require a needle and a blood sample, breath tests are non-invasive. This makes them more comfortable for the driver and quicker to administer.
- Widely Available: Breath tests are standard and can be conducted at virtually any police station or roadside, making them more accessible to law enforcement.
The Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC Team
Disadvantages of Breath Tests
- Accuracy Issues: Breath tests are subject to a margin of error. The most common issue is a malfunction or improper calibration of the breathalyzer machine. Even minor malfunctions can result in inaccurate readings. Additionally, factors like the driver’s physical condition, mouth alcohol, or medical issues such as acid reflux can distort the results.
- Human Error: Breath tests depend heavily on how they are administered. If the officer does not follow proper procedures, it can lead to challenges in court. Furthermore, the test requires the driver to provide a proper breath sample, and failure to do so could invalidate the results.
- Legal Challenges: Breath tests can be contested in court for issues such as improper maintenance of equipment, failure to calibrate the device correctly, or errors in the administration of the test. Skilled attorneys can challenge the validity of the test results based on these factors.
Blood Tests: More Accurate, But More Complex
Blood tests are often regarded as more accurate than breath tests because they directly measure the alcohol content in the bloodstream. When a blood test is ordered, a sample of the driver’s blood is drawn and sent to a laboratory for analysis. The blood is then tested to determine the exact BAC at the time of the test.Advantages of Blood Tests
- Higher Accuracy: Blood tests provide a more accurate measurement of BAC compared to breath tests. Since the sample comes directly from the bloodstream, there is less room for error in determining the actual BAC.
- Can Detect Other Substances: Blood tests can identify the presence of other substances in the driver’s system, such as drugs, which breath tests cannot detect. This can be crucial if the driver is suspected of being impaired by drugs rather than alcohol.
- Reliable in Court: Because blood tests are seen as more precise, they often hold up better in court than breath test results. Defense attorneys have fewer avenues to challenge the accuracy of blood test results compared to breath tests.
Case Results
Disadvantages of Blood Tests
- Invasiveness: Blood tests are more invasive than breath tests, as they require a needle to draw blood from the driver’s arm. This process is not only uncomfortable but also more time-consuming and can lead to issues with consent, especially if the driver refuses to comply.
- Time Delay: Unlike breath tests, which provide immediate results, blood tests require a laboratory analysis. This means there is typically a delay before the BAC results are available. This delay can be significant in DWI cases because the driver’s BAC may change over time, especially if alcohol is still being absorbed into the bloodstream.
- Potential for Contamination: Blood samples must be handled and stored properly to avoid contamination. Any mistakes in the handling or storage of the blood sample can lead to challenges in court.