What a Criminal Defense Lawyer Looks for in Police Reports

When facing criminal charges, understanding how a criminal defense lawyer analyzes police reports is essential. These documents can play a pivotal role in shaping the defense strategy and potentially altering the case’s outcome. Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC, works diligently to scrutinize police reports, identifying errors, inconsistencies, or biases that may benefit the client. In this guide, we explore what criminal defense attorneys specifically look for in these reports and how they can impact the defense’s approach.

Awards & Media Appearances

The Role of Police Reports in Criminal Defense

Police reports serve as official records of the events leading to an arrest. They provide details about the investigation, the observations made by officers, and the evidence gathered. For a criminal defense lawyer, these documents are vital in crafting a strategy to defend the client. While police reports are essential to the prosecution’s case, they are not always accurate, complete, or free from bias. Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC, understands the critical importance of examining every line in these reports to identify any weaknesses that could help the client’s defense.

Dissecting the Report: Key Areas of Focus

A criminal defense lawyer’s job is to carefully analyze the details within the police report. Several aspects of these reports come under close scrutiny, and each element can be pivotal in formulating a defense strategy.

1. Officer’s Observations and Subjectivity

The officer’s observations are often a critical part of the report. However, these observations are not always objective. Criminal defense lawyers pay particular attention to subjective language in the officer’s account. Words such as “appeared” or “seemed” are common in reports when an officer has not definitively established facts. For instance, phrases like “he appeared intoxicated” or “she seemed nervous” can be based on the officer’s personal feelings or biases, rather than concrete evidence. A defense lawyer will challenge these subjective statements by looking for evidence that either contradicts or fails to substantiate these perceptions. In addition to subjectivity, criminal defense lawyers look for instances of racial or cultural bias that could have influenced the officer’s report. If a report shows signs of bias, it can be crucial in questioning the credibility of the arrest and the officer’s actions.

The Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC Team

Jonathan Zendeh Del

Trial Attorney

Gabe Perez

Trial Attorney

Carolyn Zendeh Del

Certified Mediator, Attorney

Chase Waterwall

Trial Attorney

Dorothy Porretto

Office Manager, Paralegal

Pedro Ruiz

Judge

Zaira Banda

Legal Assistant

Colleen Herndon

Legal Assistant

2. Identifying Errors or Omissions

Police reports must be detailed and accurate. A lawyer’s job is to identify errors, inconsistencies, or omissions that can damage the credibility of the report. For example, if an officer fails to mention critical evidence or misrepresents the timeline of events, these discrepancies may indicate a flawed investigation. Lawyers will look for contradictions between the police report and other sources of evidence, such as video footage, witness statements, or forensic analysis. Even a seemingly minor detail, such as an incorrect description of the defendant’s clothing, can be used to question the accuracy of the officer’s memory and judgment.

3. Probable Cause and Legal Justification

One of the most significant aspects of a police report is the officer’s justification for the arrest or search. A defense attorney will closely examine whether the officer had probable cause to take action. Probable cause is a fundamental requirement for arrests, searches, and seizures under the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. If the police report fails to demonstrate valid probable cause, the evidence gathered during the arrest or search may be inadmissible in court. For instance, if an officer conducted a search without sufficient reason or beyond the scope allowed by law, the defense lawyer could argue that the evidence was obtained illegally, leading to a potential dismissal of charges. Scrutinizing the legality of actions taken by law enforcement is an essential part of the defense strategy.

Client
Reviews

See what our past clients have to say about us.

These guys are amazing. They made a most horrific experience bearable. They treated me with respect and no judgment. I cannot describe how grateful I am for their representation with my case. 5 stars is not enough. I hope I never need them again but would ABSOLUTELY use them again and definitely recommend them.

— Jennifer S.

Jonathan Zendeh Del and Associates worked tirelessly on my case. They kept me informed every step of the way. In the end the got my case dismissed and I am so grateful that we out our trust in his law firm. I can honestly say the rumors were true. He really is the best.

— Kristin F.

4. Miranda Rights and Confessions

Another crucial area that a criminal defense lawyer examines is whether the defendant was properly informed of their Miranda rights. If an officer failed to read the defendant their rights before questioning, any statements made by the defendant during the interrogation may be inadmissible in court. The police report should indicate if the defendant was given their Miranda warning, and defense attorneys look for any inconsistencies in the report regarding this. If there is any indication that the defendant’s rights were violated, a defense lawyer can move to have any confessions or statements suppressed.

5. Handling of Evidence and Witness Statements

Police reports often include details about evidence collected at the crime scene and witness statements. A defense lawyer will scrutinize how the evidence was collected, preserved, and handled. Any lapses in the chain of custody could be grounds for challenging the admissibility of physical evidence. Additionally, witness statements included in the report can provide valuable insights into the case. If the police report inaccurately portrays the statements of witnesses or omits critical testimony, the defense lawyer will highlight these issues to cast doubt on the prosecution’s case.

Case Results

$11,820,000

WARN ACT
SETTLEMENT

Reached a settlement of $11,820,000

$11,820,000

WARN ACT CASE
SETTLEMENT

Employees fired when not given proper notice

Not Guilty

DRUG JURY TRIAL

Client was a dentist caught with 12 grams of methamphetamine. 

Case Dismissed

DRAM SHOP CASE

Death of a person who was run over by a drunk person who left a party.

$2,500,000

CAR ACCIDENT

Confidential settlement of $2,500,000

$4,500,000

DRAM SHOP CASE

Death of a person who was run over by a drunk person who left a party

Not Guilty

DWI JURY TRIAL

Client was asleep on the side of the road with the car on. Breath was .248

Case Dismissed

STATE OF TEXAS v. C.S.

Wrecked motorcycle while leaving the beach, an officer witnessed the accident and assumed he was intoxicated

 

The Importance of Thorough Analysis

The ability to thoroughly analyze a police report is one of the most important skills a criminal defense lawyer can possess. At Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC, attorneys are trained to dissect these reports with precision, seeking out errors, inconsistencies, and omissions that could work in the client’s favor. The more attention to detail put into the analysis, the more likely a defense lawyer is to uncover weaknesses that can be exploited in court.

Police Report Analysis and Case Strategy

Once a criminal defense lawyer has thoroughly reviewed the police report, they can begin to craft a strategy for the case. If the report contains significant issues—such as an officer acting outside the law, biased observations, or unreliable evidence—the defense may focus on challenging the prosecution’s case based on these points. In some cases, a lawyer may even file motions to suppress evidence or request the dismissal of charges. On the other hand, if the police report is strong and the evidence is clear, the defense strategy may shift to focus on minimizing the charges or seeking a plea deal. Regardless of the case’s specifics, the police report analysis is the foundation upon which the defense lawyer builds their approach. In criminal defense, police reports hold significant weight. A defense lawyer’s ability to challenge these reports can make the difference between a conviction and an acquittal. By carefully analyzing every detail—officer statements, errors, omissions, probable cause, Miranda rights, and the handling of evidence—criminal defense lawyers can uncover flaws in the prosecution’s case and protect their client’s rights. If you are facing criminal charges, it is essential to have an experienced attorney who knows how to effectively examine police reports and use them to your advantage. For expert legal defense in Galveston, contact Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC, today for a consultation. Let us put our experience and commitment to work for you.

To learn more about this subject click here: Safeguarding Your Rights: Unveiling the Power of the Fourth Amendment in Criminal Defense