Texas DWI Blood vs. Breath Tests: Which Evidence Holds Up in Galveston County Courts?

When a person is arrested for a DWI in Texas, the evidence collected from chemical tests becomes a critical aspect of the case. In particular, the breath and blood tests are the most common forms of testing used to determine a person’s blood alcohol content (BAC). In Galveston County, as in other parts of Texas, understanding the differences between these tests, how they are administered, and how they are treated in the courts can have significant consequences. 

Awards & Media Appearances

Understanding Breath Tests and Blood TestsTexas DWI Blood vs. Breath Tests: Which Evidence Holds Up in Galveston County Courts?

Breath and blood tests are both designed to measure the amount of alcohol in a person’s system, but they do so in different ways. Breath tests involve using a machine to analyze the alcohol content in a person’s breath, which is then used to estimate their BAC. Blood tests, on the other hand, measure the alcohol content in a person’s blood, and many argue that they are more accurate than breath tests. Both types of tests have their strengths and weaknesses, and each comes with its own legal considerations.

How Breath Tests Are Conducted

A breath test is typically the first method of testing that is offered when a driver is arrested for suspicion of DWI. This is because breath tests are quick, easy to administer, and the results can often be available within minutes. To conduct a breath test, law enforcement will ask the individual to blow into a breathalyzer device. This device measures the amount of alcohol in the breath, which is then used to estimate the individual’s BAC. In Texas, a BAC of 0.08% or higher is considered legally intoxicated, and if the breathalyzer shows that a person’s BAC is at or above this level, it can serve as strong evidence in the case. However, breath tests are not always foolproof. One of the most common issues with breath tests is the potential for inaccuracies due to the calibration of the breathalyzer machine or improper handling by the officer administering the test. In some cases, faulty machines or improper procedures can lead to false results, which can be challenged in court.

The Zendeh Del & Associates, PLLC Team

Jonathan Zendeh Del

Trial Attorney

Gabe Perez

Trial Attorney

Carolyn Zendeh Del

Certified Mediator, Attorney

Chase Waterwall

Trial Attorney

Dorothy Porretto

Office Manager, Paralegal

Pedro Ruiz

Judge

Legal Assistant Zaira Banda

Zaira Banda

Legal Assistant

Legal Assistant Colleen Herndon

Colleen Herndon

Legal Assistant

The Reliability of Blood Tests

Blood tests are often considered more accurate than breath tests because they directly measure the alcohol content in a person’s blood. Blood tests are typically conducted when a breath test is unavailable, when the officer suspects the driver is under the influence of substances other than alcohol, or if the individual has refused to take the breath test. While blood tests are generally more reliable, they also come with their own set of challenges. First, blood tests take longer to process, and the results are not immediately available like breath test results. In addition, blood samples must be collected in a sterile environment by trained professionals to avoid contamination. There is also the potential for errors during the handling, storage, and transportation of blood samples. Any break in the chain of custody—meaning any step in the process where the sample may have been compromised or mishandled—can lead to the evidence being inadmissible in court.

The Legal Implications of Breath and Blood Tests in Galveston County Courts

The role that breath and blood test results play in a DWI case in Galveston County can vary depending on the circumstances surrounding the arrest. In Galveston County, like elsewhere in Texas, evidence from both breath and blood tests is treated seriously, but both types of tests can be challenged in court.

Client
Reviews

See what our past clients have to say about us.

These guys are amazing. They made a most horrific experience bearable. They treated me with respect and no judgment. I cannot describe how grateful I am for their representation with my case. 5 stars is not enough. I hope I never need them again but would ABSOLUTELY use them again and definitely recommend them.

— Jennifer S.

Jonathan Zendeh Del and Associates worked tirelessly on my case. They kept me informed every step of the way. In the end the got my case dismissed and I am so grateful that we out our trust in his law firm. I can honestly say the rumors were true. He really is the best.

— Kristin F.

Breath Tests and Their Challenges in Court

In Galveston County courts, as in other jurisdictions, breath test results can be contested based on the accuracy and maintenance of the breathalyzer machine. Defense attorneys may argue that the machine was not properly calibrated, or that the officer administering the test was not properly trained. Additionally, breath test results can be influenced by a variety of factors, such as medical conditions like acid reflux, which may cause alcohol to be present in the breath even if the person has not been drinking. There have been cases where breath test results were thrown out due to issues with the accuracy of the breathalyzer machine or the procedures used in administering the test. When the breath test results are challenged, it is up to the defense attorney to raise reasonable doubt about the validity of the evidence.

Blood Tests and Their Legal Scrutiny

While blood tests are often considered more reliable than breath tests, they are not immune to challenges in court. In Galveston County, blood test results can be scrutinized in cases where there is a question about the proper handling and chain of custody of the blood sample. For example, if the blood sample was not stored properly or if there is evidence of contamination, the defense may argue that the blood test results should not be admissible.

Case Results

$11,820,000

WARN ACT
SETTLEMENT

Reached a settlement of $11,820,000

$11,820,000

WARN ACT CASE
SETTLEMENT

Employees fired when not given proper notice

Not Guilty

DRUG JURY TRIAL

Client was a dentist caught with 12 grams of methamphetamine. 

Case Dismissed

DRAM SHOP CASE

Death of a person who was run over by a drunk person who left a party.

$2,500,000

CAR ACCIDENT

Confidential settlement of $2,500,000

$4,500,000

DRAM SHOP CASE

Death of a person who was run over by a drunk person who left a party

Not Guilty

DWI JURY TRIAL

Client was asleep on the side of the road with the car on. Breath was .248

Case Dismissed

STATE OF TEXAS v. C.S.

Wrecked motorcycle while leaving the beach, an officer witnessed the accident and assumed he was intoxicated

Another potential issue with blood tests is the time it takes for the results to be processed. In many cases, blood test results may not be available until weeks after the arrest, which can create complications in a DWI case. The longer the delay between the arrest and the testing, the more room there is for questioning the accuracy of the results, especially in cases where a person’s BAC could have changed over time.

Which Test Holds More Weight in Galveston County?

When it comes to determining which test holds more weight in Galveston County courts, the answer is not always clear-cut. In general, blood tests are considered more reliable due to their accuracy in measuring BAC directly from a person’s blood. However, breath tests are much more commonly used because they can be administered quickly and easily at the scene of the arrest. That being said, both tests can be used effectively in a DWI case in Galveston County, and both are subject to challenges in court. For breath tests, defense attorneys may focus on issues such as improper calibration, inaccurate readings, or improper procedures. For blood tests, the primary concern often revolves around the chain of custody and potential contamination of the sample. Ultimately, the strength of the evidence in any given case will depend on the specifics of the arrest and the procedures followed by law enforcement. An experienced DWI attorney can help individuals facing DWI charges navigate these complexities and determine the best defense strategy based on the evidence presented.

Working with an Experienced DWI Attorney

If you have been arrested for a DWI in Galveston County, understanding the implications of breath and blood tests is crucial. An experienced DWI attorney can help you evaluate the evidence in your case and determine whether there are any grounds to challenge the results of the breath or blood tests. At Zendeh Del & Associates PLLC, our legal team has extensive experience defending clients against DWI charges in Galveston County. We understand the intricacies of both breath and blood tests and how they are treated in court. Our attorneys can help you build a strong defense strategy tailored to your case and work to get the best possible outcome for you. If you’ve been charged with a DWI in Galveston County, don’t wait to seek legal representation. Contact Zendeh Del & Associates PLLC today for a free consultation. We’ll help you understand your options, evaluate the evidence in your case, and fight to protect your rights.

To learn more about this subject click here: A New Law Could Change Everything for Immigrants Convicted of DUI—Here’s What You Need to Know